Posted in match reports

View from the South Stand: Sale Sharks 38 Exeter Chiefs 24 (PRC)

Now that’s more like it…

For the most part, this was a game that delivered on last week’s first-half promise. It was not perfect, by any means: indeed, large parts of the first half seemed like a continuation of the second half from last week, and the defence could best be described as “porous” for the Exeter tries.

But, on the whole, this team worked well and deserved all six tries.


Things got off to a somewhat inauspicious start when Exeter scored an unconverted try ten minutes in. (Checking the highlights later showed a clear forward pass to the scorer. QI klaxon for the officials, there: minus ten points.) Two minutes later, though, Sale were on the attack and Ollie Davies put up an inch-perfect cross-field kick to Alex Wills. A simple finish, a simple conversion and we were two points up.

A few minutes after that, Brown-Bampoe was sent to the bin, which left enough of a gap in the Exeter defensive line for Rikki to more or less stroll through for Sale’s second try. A nice way to mark your 50th appearance for the club.

Nine points up, happy days.

Except for the fly in the ointment: the scrum was getting beaten up pretty regularly throughout the game. I think almost every Exeter put-in ended with a free kick or penalty to them. I can only remember one that went the other way, when they were pinged for an early engage.

On the bright side, though, the lineouts were working well, as were the close-range mauls.

So, things were looking mostly good, but then the penalties started flowing (I know, I was shocked, too) and Exeter started getting back into the game. And so, inevitably, on the stroke of half-time, they scored through a sadly porous defence to go in only two points behind and snapping at our heels.


Last week, I was bemoaning the fact that David Opoku-Fordjour was left on the bench all game, when his speed could have made a big difference. Well, this week, he came on a minute after the break as a replacement for Rikki, so that was an improvement. Maybe for the next game, they could take the next step and actually give him the ball occasionally. Just thought I’d run that idea up the flagpole…

As it happens, the second half was mostly dominated by the forwards: three mauled tries and a penalty try that would have been a mauled try if Exeter hadn’t pulled it down. Incidentally, that penalty try should have been Jibs’s hat-trick – I think he can feel justifiably annoyed at being denied it.

Exeter scored two tries of their own in the second half, interleaved with Sale’s mauled tries. Sadly, in both cases, they came from woeful tackling by Sale. Something to be worked on, there.


So, that leaves us currently top of our half of the competition, mainly down to being the last team to have a bye week and to having three home games to one away.

As an aside, who organises the schedule, anyway? It means that we end up having just one men’s home game during the entire Six Nations dry spell. Thank goodness for the women’s competition…

If Exeter beat Gloucester this weekend, we stay top, otherwise we drop to second.


I thought Ollie Davies had a very impressive game. His kicking, both off the tee and tactically, was spot on. I said four tries came from powerful mauls: well, it was Ollie’s kicking that set up the position in the first place. I’m tempted to suggest that he should be given the nod for when Exeter come back up in a couple of weeks for the PREM game.

Dom Hanson is developing nicely into an archetypal scrummie – sharp, feisty, quick, abrasive… He could well be the next Raffi, but without the injury problems (fingers crossed).

Jibs made a big difference when he came on. Alfie played well, but Jibs just brought that bit extra to the final half hour. And his lineout throwing was good, too. Let’s hope he can keep it to that standard in future games. I’m definitely looking forward to a Jibs/Alfie pairing when Dickie finally moves on.


The men have a couple of weekends off now, but the women start their PWR campaign this weekend at Heywood Road against Gloucester-Hartpury. That should be fun, considering how many players we nicked off them at the end of last season. I’m looking forward to seeing Tatyana Heard lining up against her former teammates (or, rather, I’m looking forward to watching Tatyana play full stop).

Pre-season, we expected so much from both teams but (so far) the men have let us down, so I’m looking to the women to provide the joie de vivre for this season. No pressure, then, ladies…

Posted in match reports

View from here and there: A double header of sorts

Well, that was a fun day – heading up to Heywood Road first thing for the women’s game, then dashing off to the Trafford Centre to catch the men playing later in the afternoon.

It’s been a busy week for me following those two games, so this is going to be a quick recap of them, more for the sake of publishing something than to do any in-depth analysis. I should be back to more ‘normal’ screeds once the PREMiership gets under way.

Sale Sharks 14 Saracens 27 (PWRC)

Given that in last year’s PWR, Saracens were 26-0 up by half-time, this defeat is still evidence of a remarkable improvement in the Sale women’s team.

I’m not going to read anything into this performance: I know that both teams are missing players, but I’ve seen enough to anticipate at least a decent mid-table finish this year. As I said last week, there’s something different about the team’s approach. It’s hard to quantify, but it mostly comes down to a feeling: that there’s more purpose about their play, a stronger intent.

And, let’s face it, Saracens were flattered by the scoreline. It was only a breakaway try when Sale were pressing for a potentially winning score that made the gap as wide as it is.

I’ve still got a good feeling about this season.

Sale Sharks 24 Bristol Bears 15 (PRC)

And so, over to what we now have to call the other Corpaq Stadium for the men to take on Bristol.

I was a bit apprehensive about this, as we were fielding a very mixed first/academy team (with significant international absences). In contrast, Bristol seemed to be taking it seriously, with many of their top players out there.

The first seemed to justify the gloomy predictions, as Bristol piled on a 12-5 lead by halftime, without seeming to be trying.

But then, Sale seem to have the measure of Bristol. Keep van Rensburg and Ibitoye quiet, and Briz don’t have the fluency that they’re known for.

So it was that the tide turned in the second half as converted tries from Jibulu and Hanson took Sale to a seven-point lead. McGinty pulled a penalty back, but a late try from Ollie Davis meant we took the full five points from the game and denied Bristol anything.


Kudos this week to all the women against Sarries. What I said last week still applies, and again I’m going to single out Sharifa Kasolo. Very impressive.

The men all stepped up following the game that shall not be mentioned the week before. It was a shame that Obi Ene went off injured after half an hour, as he’s looked good every time I’ve watched him. Lots of potential there.

I think we may have a second Asher in the shape of our new hooker: that was a seriously impressive outing. And, yes, I’m going to say it…

I like the cut of his jib.

Sorry.

I thought Tom Curtis had his best game in a while, and Flats seems to have found the fountain of youth.


So, that’s it for the men: one game, then a bye week. Hardly seems worth it, does it? Come back a week later for the first of four PREMiership games in four months up to the end of the year. Talk about giving the supporters what they want and keeping the crowd’s interest…

Yes, actually, can we talk about that? Because the powers that be don’t seem to give a toss.

As for the women, they go down to Bristol for round four of the PWRC. A win there should see them through to the knock-out stages (although it’s hard to be sure as the PWR website is woefully short of useful details like tables and so on). Good luck to them, but even if they don’t manage the win, they’ve shown me enough that I’m looking forward to the league campaign.

Posted in match reports

View from the south stand: Sale 64 Ampthill 0 [PRC]

I’ve said before that I don’t enjoy watching one-sided matches. Thankfully, this should be the last weekend of them, both domestically and in that competition going on over in France.

This week alone has seen scores of 64–0, 98–14, 68–10 and 82–12.

Does either team get anything out of this sort of mismatch, other than game time? Is it really the case that being on the wrong end of a drubbing is a “good experience”? It’s one thing to lose but feel that you gave a good account of yourself (q.v. Caldy last week); it’s something else to be totally outclassed: that has to be demoralising.

And what about dishing it out? Do you really learn anything about your own capabilities? What does beating up a part-time scrum tell you about how you’re going to get on when Northampton come calling?

These sort of drubbings against what should be closely matched teams concerns me at times. It suggests that there is a superficiality to the game, both nationally and internationally. All looks great at the top, but one level down is too far away in ability for it to be healthy.

I don’t have any answers, it’s just that the sorts of mismatches that have happened over the last few weeks (not to mention the collapse of three Premiership clubs in one season) expose, I feel, a systemic problem in the world game. And that makes me less than sanguine about the future.


Rant over, back to business.

First off, let’s hear it for Ampthill. Outclassed, maybe, but they never gave up and even had some genuine opportunities right at the end. They could have put points on the board with a couple of penalty awards late on but chose instead to go for the big prize. After all, what’s the difference between 64–0 and 64–3? But to pull a try back: that would have been something to take home. That they didn’t manage it is – almost – irrelevant: the heart was there.

For Sale, Cobus marching out in the second half was the highlight for me – he can make (and made) a big difference. It leaves us a Curry or two short of our ideal back-five selection pool but we’re in a good place. Tommy Taylor’s return eases a few worries about the pack: Ethan Caine is a real prospect but we do need an old, wise head around and with LCD a doubt and Creevy still in France, TT gives us a stable base in the front row.

Raffi’s looking sharp again. It’s going to be a major battle between him and Gus for the starting spot, especially given Gus’s obvious ability from the tee now making him a viable back-up kicker.

On the downside, though, I counted some six butchered chances at the start of the second half. All of them – if I remember correctly – dropped balls just metres from the line. This is a bit concerning because we won’t get away with that when the proper games start up next week. Basic skills, guys, basic skills.


Looking back at the last five weeks, we’ve seen some younger and fringe players given the chance to show what they can do and, almost unanimously, putting their hands up to say “I’m here, and I’m good enough”. We have some good talent coming through; I’m looking forward to watching them make their marks in the Premiership in the coming seasons.

We’ve also given the established guys a chance to blow off the cobwebs and, apart from a – by the sounds of it – sub-par performance against Newcastle and the butchering of chances here, things seem to be ramping up nicely ready for the real tests to come.


And on that note: Northampton come calling next up. We beat them here last year but, if memory serves, it was not entirely comfortable. I’ve got a bit lost over the summer concerning who has picked up whom; who has made major improvements to the squad; and who we should be watching out for this year (usual suspects aside).

Given that we have Leicester away and Exeter away in rounds two and three, we could really do with getting off to a good start in this game, and the Super Accurate Magic Predictor™ gives us some hope:

SAMP–5Sale 26 – 15 Saints
SAMP–10Sale 22 – 15 Saints

Can’t wait…